Results

Trending topics

Select your station

We'll remember your choice for next time

Kane Cornes' seven observations from Round 9 of the 2023 AFL season

2023-05-16T13:55+10:00

Kane Cornes has handed down his weekly observations following the Round 9 action of the 2023 AFL season.

From more chapters to simmering feuds, a question mark on the Tigers, concerns with contracts and more, read on to see what caught Cornes' eye on the weekend.

1. Is Richmond’s winning brand sustainable?

“I think the performance was admirable and they dug deep to produce it and they got themselves up for a big Friday night game, it was a trademark performance, the pressure was back…” Cornes began.

“I just don’t know if it’s sustainable. Clearly, Geelong’s injuries were a factor, not saying Richmond doesn’t have a couple of key players out but they always seem to.

“Nine out of their best 22, the Cats. They kicked 2.7 in the first quarter, they dominated contested ball and I think Richmond lose that game eight out of 10 times.

“You’re never going to get three goals from (Trent) Cotchin again, for the rest of his career.”

2. The most unlikely MOTY contender

“The most unlikely player in the league emerged as a genuine mark of the year contender.

“Patrick Parnell is 177cms, he’s 71 kilograms and he had never taken a contested mark in his career prior to sitting on someone’s head at the Adelaide Oval.

“Unbelievable… the odds he would have been to take Mark of the Year at the start of the season…”

3. Is Aidan Corr in the conversation as the league’s most overpaid player?

“He is the 300th-rated player in the league by Champion Data and I’m not sure if he’s ever influenced a result.

“He got five years (on a contract at North Melbourne, reports say it’s somewhere between 550k and 700k). I know it’s five years but I’m more worried about the figure.

“It’s too much. Reversing free kicks at the top of the goal square for a senior player and then getting yourself suspended when you’ve got six injuries on the day…

“I thought that was one of the more ordinary things I’ve seen this year and you have to be careful with your recruiting.

“You can chuck Griffin Logue in there too. Five years, massive money, it is laughable, honestly. Who make these decisions, there is no accountability for when they get them wrong.”

4. My man Jason Horne-Francis has now had 53 clearances for the year

“It’s 10 more than North’s leading clearance player, Luke Davies-Uniacke, and that’s just an observation, I don’t need any more comment on that.

“I just wanted to observe he’s had 10 more clearances than the next best player at North Melbourne.

“I think it is a reasonable observation that he as a 19-year-old has 10 more clearances than the next best North Melbourne player.”

5. Hold off on measuring Tim English for his All-Australian blazer

“Sean Darcy is emerging. 18 possessions, 44 hitouts, nine clearances, eight inside 50s and seven score involvements (on the weekend).

“John Longmire spoke after the game about the clearances in the second quarter… he said, ‘we just got smashed’.

“He said he’s never seen numbers like it before and that is surprising for Sydney… their midfield, their personnel is pretty good.”

__6. The best midfield duo in the competition under the age 24?

“Connor Rozee and Zak Butters were picks 5 and 11 in the 2018 draft… (Matt) Rowell and (Noah) Anderson (are in the mix), I reckon there would be a good level of competition between those two midfields.

“They’re probably the two young midfield duos in the competition doing big things.

“Zak Butters is fourth in the coaches votes now, he’s snuck up on a few people I reckon.

“I’m not saying I would take Butters and Rozee, I’m just saying it’s a good debate to have.”

7. Another Taranto observation

“I just want to highlight that I don’t say things for the sake of it as much as I don’t need to defend myself.

“But after Tim Taranto had only two effective kicks and eight clangers on Friday night, he has dropped from the 121st-rated player in the game to 141st.

“I just wanted to highlight that and that is an observation that once again doesn’t need any comment, it’s just a fact. Just a cold, hard fact that I thought I’d highlight.”

More in AFL

Featured