Hawthorn great Luke Hodge has urged Carlton to try a different look when coming up against a side as talented as Brisbane.
The Lions handled the Blues in convincing fashion in Friday night's blockbuster, taking down Carlton by 26 points as the boos began to rain down on the Blues at several stages of the match.
Carlton lost the match through the middle two quarters, kicking just 1.4 in that time as their uninspired ball movement saw their attack become completely ineffective.
While reigning Coleman Medallist Charlie Curnow kicked nine goals the previous round playing as a deep forward, Hodge believes bringing the superstar further up the ground could have solved many of the Blues’ issues.
“The forward structure, if you’re Curnow on (Jack) Payne, why do you keep him deep, he’s so good at having the game in front of him,” he said on SEN’s Crunch Time.
“Put Curnow up the ground, we know he’s an athlete, lose Payne and that means you get a different side in front of the football”
“I didn’t think they changed enough centre-forward to give the mids a different look or to make Payne play out of position.”
While Carlton’s strategy was more than enough to dominate the hapless West Coast Eagles in Round 7, Hodge doesn’t think that’s reason to stick with the approach against a far better side like the Lions.
“(Curnow) had one kick in a half of football, their supporters left during the third quarter because during quarters two and three it was 7.6 to 1.4,” he said.
“Because they played that structure they played last week against a team that have 25 people to pick from.
“Against the Lions, when you’ve got a young person, make him look different, if he’s looking as comfortable as what he is against Curnow, put him up the ground.
“(Harry) McKay is a Coleman Medallist, put him down on Harris Andrews, let’s see how Harris Andrews’ agility is in the forward 50 against McKay who is agile for a bloke who’s 6’5”.
“I just thought if you’re trying to do the same thing against a team who’s clearly got it over you, and the defender is playing a pretty good job on a person who kicked nine last week, you can change it up.”
While Brisbane defender Jack Payne did a terrific job limiting Curnow on Friday night, Hodge is certain that the simple change of making him play further up the ground would have completely changed the dynamic.
“We look at Jack Payne and say how good has he been this year and he really took steps, the longest streak he’d played before this year was five games… this year he’s played all eight so he’s starting to get a little bit of confidence,” he said.
“You take him away from where he normally plays and put him up at centre half-back, next thing the game is behind him, Curnow might swing around, he’s not watching the ball.
“It just puts that little bit of doubt, and then it gives the strength of Curnow, who’s an athletic piece… he can lead up, he can lead back, he can lead left and right, rather than just leading up at the ball.”
Carlton will be looking to bounce back strongly next round, taking on the Bulldogs on Saturday night at Marvel Stadium.