Results

Trending topics

Select your station

We'll remember your choice for next time

Evaluating the performances of every new AFL captain after six rounds

2023-04-28T08:52+10:00

Former Western Bulldogs skipper Brad Johnson has gone through the nine AFL teams with new captains and given an evaluation of their performances after six weeks.

Adelaide, Brisbane, Collingwood, Essendon, Fremantle, North Melbourne, GWS, Geelong and Hawthorn have all made changes to who leads their respective clubs.

Johnson, alongside Gerard Healy and Kane Cornes gave some early thoughts on how each new skipper is going on SEN’s Sportsday.

Jordan Dawson (Adelaide)

Johnson: “On-field, he’s gone to another level. He’s been given opportunities in the midfield and I think as a captain that’s critical as well.”

Cornes: “He says all the right things. He’s calm, he doesn’t seem to have changed his demeanour at all, there’s a nice humble nature about him, but there’s an air of authority about him. I’ve been really impressed by the presence he’s got. He couldn’t have started better.”

Lachie Neale and Harris Andrews (Brisbane)

Johnson: “Neale and Andrews was always going to work because of their experience. I like the combination of a midfielder with a key defender.”

Cornes: “I wasn’t sure about Andrews to be honest, but he has really impressed me with his on-field form as well.”

Johnson: “Andrews needed to turn a few things around and the captaincy has allowed him to do that.”

Darcy Moore (Collingwood)

Johnson: “I think the way he spoke on Anzac Day says it all.”

Healy: “Probably his start to the season was a little bit slow, more just total defence than attack, but his last three games have been superstar level.”

Zach Merrett (Essendon)

Johnson: “I think he has handled that really well. He’s been part of my rolling All-Australian throughout the year and that combination with Parish has been good so I’ll give him a tick.”

Alex Pearce (Fremantle)

Johnson: “Out of the nine, he’s probably the one feeling it the most because they’re under the most pressure with what they’d be trying to do to keep the playing group energised and the performances they’re putting out. He’s got his own challenges and playing as a key defender makes it even more difficult on game day when things aren’t going your way.”

Cornes: “Looks slow to me, Alex Pearce. Struggling to cover the ground I reckon and he’s had his issues with his body. But he’s not the only Fremantle player who looks slow.”

Patrick Dangerfield (Geelong)

Johnson: “I think things are starting to come together for Danger, he’s building into the year.”

Healy: “The criticism came early for Dangerfield and I thought it was over the top.”

Johnson: “I think that was purely about his form and now he’s starting to get going.”

Toby Greene (GWS)

Johnson: “I think he’s answered the question for Adam Kingsley at GWS. Just his presence is strong and he’s playing great football and it hasn’t affected him one bit as one-out captain.”

Cornes: “Couldn’t be doing any more, Toby Greene.”

James Sicily (Hawthorn)

Johnson: “I didn’t have an issue (with his Tassie comments), but when you’re the captain of the club, you’ve got to understand all aspects of what the club is doing and what they’ve done in the past. With Sicily, he’s doing such a great job on the field as a new captain though.”

Luke McDonald and Jy Simpkin (North Melbourne)

Johnson: “I think Simpkin in particular has been really good. McDonald throws his body on the line and sets a great example and fights out of his weight division. They’ve got a lot of work to do as on-field leaders in terms of the structure Alastair Clarkson is trying to implement because at the moment they’re leaking a lot and he’s part of that leak.”

Healy: “They’ve got some work to do. They’ve gone backwards since Ben McKay’s come back into the defence and they need to address the issues.”

Sportsday

More in AFL

Featured