West Coast coach Adam Simpson believes Tim Kelly has been unfairly criticised since he became an Eagle.
Kelly’s move back home to Perth from Geelong in late 2019 has been well documented over the years given the Eagles gave up picks 14, 27 and 37 as well as a future first-rounder for the midfielder.
While in royal blue and gold, the 28-year-old has failed to hit the immense heights he set during his two-years stint with the Cats but Simpson has been happy with his output, particularly in 2023.
Across four rounds this year, Kelly is averaging a massive 30.8 disposals plus 5.2 marks, 4.8 clearances, 4.2 inside 50s, three tackles and a goal which has him sitting third on the AFLCA Champion Player of the Year award with 22 votes.
Simpson insists Kelly has had a burden to carry over the last few seasons with the Eagles constantly dealing with injuries to their prime movers.
“He’s copped a lot since we recruited him,” Simpson said on SEN WA Breakfast.
“Sometimes with what’s happening with our side he’s on his own. He’s had a real focus in the off-season to get as fit as he can.
“I think he’s coming second or third in the coaches voting which is a really good indicator of your form.
“We still think there’s plenty of footy in front of him. I think he’s going to pay us back, but he owes us nothing to be honest.
“He’s been really good for us since he’s been here, but this year in particular he’s stood up.”
Kelly and the Eagles will take on his former club the Cats at Adelaide Oval on Sunday on the fourth day of Gather Round.
He picked up 28 touches the last time West Coast played Geelong in Round 23 last year.