Results

Trending topics

Select your station

We'll remember your choice for next time

The cascading consequences of GWS re-signing Stephen Coniglio

2023-03-15T10:24+11:00

GWS’ decision to make Stephen Coniglio captain as seemingly part of his re-signing with the club had enormous ramifications on the culture at the Giants, ultimately leading to the departure of star forward Jeremy Cameron.

That is what leading AFL journalist Sam McClure believes.

In 2019, Coniglio turned down large contracts from Carlton and Hawthorn to recommit to the Giants on a seven-year deal, reportedly worth $1.2 million per season.

McClure outlined the meeting with GWS CEO Dave Matthews that ultimately led to the star midfielder re-signing.

“So, Stephen Coniglio is out of contract. He has huge offers on the table from Hawthorn and Carlton. He’s ready to leave,” he told the Tradies podcast.

“They’ve got coach Leon Cameron, list manager Jason McCartney and then head of football Wayne Campbell all really experienced football guys. They’re sitting there going, ‘look, we love Stephen, but the reality is we’ve got Josh Kelly, we’ve got Tim Taranto, we’ve got Jacob Hopper, we’ve got Tom Green coming through, they were just about to draft Lachie Ash, they’ve got midfielders coming out of their ears’.

“They wanted to keep him, but they couldn’t offer the money that these other clubs could.

“And then one meeting between Coniglio, his high profile manager Tom Petroro, he gets deals done, and Dave Matthews the CEO, they sit down in a room as the three of them, they come out and the deal has been done. Seven years at $1.2 million.”

Stay up to date with all the latest news from SEN. Sign up HERE.

Coniglio replaced Callan Ward and Phil Davis as club captain the following season, a move that McClure intimates was seemingly part of negotiations.

“No one’s ever going to admit that (the captaincy was also part of the deal) at the club, but the facts are this – Phil Davis and Callan Ward were captains and were once again voted by the players to be captains and for whatever reason someone decided to go above and beyond, disagree with that vote, and say ‘no, Stephen will be captain’,” he said.

“I personally don’t think the Giants have ever been the same football club since then.

“I feel for the Giants and I feel for guys like Dave Matthews who have built the club from the ground because they look at all their players and all the stars who have walked out on that joint and they can’t do anything about it because they’ve got talent coming out of their ears, they have the same salary cap as everyone else, the AFL took COLA away from them and the Swans – what are they supposed to do?

“So when it came to one of their most inspirational on-field leaders, Dave and whoever else at the club sat there and went ‘no, I’m not letting them take another one. Carlton and Hawthorn can get nicked’. They weren’t going to let it happen again and if it meant Stephen needed to be captain, Phil and Callan have been great stewards of this club for a long time, their time has to come to an end at some point, why can’t it be now?”

However, that decision to override the playing group and appoint Coniglio led to a cultural shift at the club that ultimately led to Cameron leaving the club.

“I don’t begrudge the decision at the time, but these decisions have ramifications,” McClure added.

“If Stephen Coniglio leaves, there is no way Jeremy Cameron is not at the Giants right now.

“That decision to make Coniglio captain changed a lot of people’s opinions – I’m talking about the environment and the culture. Coniglio leaves, Cameron stays. Regardless (of Geelong’s offer).

“These decisions, they change the course of clubs and as I said, I’m not here blaming Dave Matthews. I’m certainly not here blaming Stephen or Tom Petroro, they got the best deal they could and Stephen at the time was worthy of a very big contract.”

Cameron was an integral part of Geelong winning the 2022 premiership, making the All-Australian team and kicking 65 goals to go with 21 goal assists and 75 inside 50s.

More in AFL

Featured