Results

Trending topics

Select your station

We'll remember your choice for next time

“Doesn’t look ready”: Agar’s Sydney performance has XI for India up in the air

2023-01-09T11:48+11:00

Ashton Agar failed to make the most of his inclusion for the Sydney Test, and the question of the second spinner for the upcoming India tour is wide open once again.

On what was tipped to be a spinning pitch, Agar was brought in for his first Test since 2017 as the Aussies searched for a series whitewash of South Africa.

But little went to plan for the home side, with rain and light issues taking more than 150 overs off the Test match.

Agar bowled 22 overs throughout the Test for no wickets and looked the least dangerous of the Aussie bowlers. The 29-year-old was admittedly rushed as the Australians searched for 20 wickets on the final two days.

Pat Cummins has since confirmed Agar will be on the plane to India, where Australia plays a four-Test series beginning in February.

However, SEN Test Cricket’s Gerard Whateley believes Agar might have lost his chance to sure up his spot in the starting XI for the first Test.

“Not nearly enough I think is the answer,” Whateley responded when asked what the Aussies learnt in the Sydney Test.

“You don’t waste a circumstance like Australia was presented with, but they never got to answer any of those questions.

“Some of the thinking will be muddied.

“Ashton Agar didn’t bowl in the manner in his return to Test cricket that would have him ready to go for the first Test in India.

“I suspect in their private planning and on their whiteboard it would have been Lyon and Agar in Nagpur, but now that they’ve seen it, Agar’s red ball bowling doesn’t look ready for that challenge.

“There’s no doubt he’ll go on the tour and Pat Cummins rallied around that last night and I totally understand that, but I don’t know if that performance actually has him in that first Test.

“I think that’s what they were looking for. I think they were looking for reassurance (that he was ready).”

With Australia only playing three specialist bowlers and Agar as the all-rounder, the West Australian only bowled less than half the overs of fellow spinner Lyon.

Agar also lacked the threat of part-time off-spinner Travis Head, who bowled better than his first innings figures of 1-21 suggest.

“He (Agar) didn’t bowl with the consistency or the threat that Test cricket demands. They weren’t the right circumstances for it, it would have been interesting to see in day four or day five on a wearing pitch, but on that evidence, I don’t think he would play at Nagpur,” Whateley continued.

“So, the second spinner question is unanswered.”

Agar replaced Cam Green as the Australian all-rounder in Sydney, and Green is in a race against time to feature in the first Test against India on February 9 after finger surgery.

Quick Mitch Starc also appears unlikely after a finger tendon injury, meaning several combinations are still on the table for the first Test.

More in Cricket

Featured