The Daily Telegraph’s Ben Horne has critcised Cricket Australia (CA) for not handling David Warner’s captaincy ban prior to the start of the Test summer which has subsequently overshadowed Australia’s dominant 419-run win over the West Indies in Adelaide.
Warner has generated headlines for the past week after he withdrew his appeal to overturn his ban as well as his manager James Erskine alleging that more players were involved in ‘sandpapergate’.
Following the win against the West Indies, Steve Smith labelled Warner's ban “fundamentally wrong” and that the 36-year-old had more than served his suspension.
Horne said Smith’s comments were telling that the players are clearly frustrated with the governing body.
“I thought it was about the most significant comment so far,” Horne said on SEN 1170 Breakfast.
“People are having their opinion on the process about whether they could’ve done this (review) internally or whether it did need to go to an independent panel.
“CA could’ve controlled, unquestionably, the timing of this.
“They had an entire off-season where this could’ve been looked at instead of the middle of the Test summer.
“You've now got players coming into press conferences being asked about it and that could’ve been avoided.
“There’s a general feeling that five years on, David Warner deserves to have (the captaincy ban) taken off his record.”
Warner averaged 25.50 with a high score of 48 against an underwhelming West Indies attack which has added pressure on the veteran opener’s place in the side beyond the summer.
Furthermore, the fitness of captain Pat Cummins will cause another selection headache after the strong performances of Scott Boland and Michael Neser in Adelaide.
“(Cummins) is definitely on track to play the next Test,” Horne continued.
“Josh Hazlewood definitely won’t play the next Test (so) I think Scott Boland (will play).
“The way Michael Neser bowled in the first innings was certainly shaping as a bit of a bowl-off in the second innings.
“(Boland and Neser) both got three wickets in the second innings.
“The nature of what Scott Boland did to start the (second) innings and the wickets he already has on the board from last summer gives Boland the edge.
“It’s an interesting conversation to have.”
The First Test against South Africa at The Gabba begins on December 17.
SEN will once again be your home of cricket this summer, with every ball of every Test broadcast live. Join our call team led by Gerard Whateley for the best call of both the West Indies and South Africa Test series.