Results

Trending topics

Select your station

We'll remember your choice for next time

“Absolute farce”: Has the AFL's rookie draft lost its purpose?

2022-12-01T09:34+11:00

Only 13 new players received opportunities in the AFL’s rookie draft, with the majority of picks those who were delisted and re-rookied.

Kane Cornes is disappointed to see the decline of the rookie draft and has called on the AFL to adjust the rules.

Recent success stories out of the rookie draft include Jack Ginnivan, Brad Close, Tom Atkins and Callum Wilkie.

“It’s a little bit disappointing to see only 59 were selected … but then to have the rookie draft today and see only 13 new players get selected, we speak about it every year, but the rookie rules and the rookie draft is an absolute farce,” Cornes told SEN’s Sportsday.

“It’s something the AFL needs to do something about. Phil Davis was selected as a rookie. He’s 32 and played 192 games.

“Ed Curnow is an AFL rookie. He’s 33, it’s his 16th season. Connor Blakely, Paul Seedsman is 30 and he’s a rookie. Kayne Turner. Daniel Howe. Nakia Cockatoo to Brisbane.

“It’s being exploited by clubs and the AFL has allowed it to happen. I loved the rookie list.

“One of my favourite teammates was Dean Brogan. Great backstory, from a basketball background … Dean Cox, Matt Priddis, Stephen Milne, Aaron Sandilands, Brett Kirk, they’re all rookies. They’re not Ed Curnow (getting re-rookied).

“In total, we’ve got 72 new players having an AFL opportunity. That is four per club and it’s not enough.

“They scrapped the veterans list. That was a great rule. The veterans list was terrific.

“I don’t think it’s a hard problem to solve. At the moment you can have between 36 and 38 primary listed players. You can have four to six Category A traditional rookies and you can have two Category B rookies.

“Just make it 44 – or bring it back to what it originally was where rookie players are between 18 and 23, they sit on your list and develop and they can only play if there’s a serious injury.

“That was a great rule and that’s where all those players came from and got their opportunities.

“But at the moment clubs are exploiting it and they’ll keep doing it until the AFL does something about it.”

AFL Draft expert Callum Twomey also gave his thoughts on the rookie draft.

“I do think it has changed from what it was brought in for, but things evolve and change,” Twomey said.

“I would like to see players who are delisted but want to get re-taken by their clubs – those clubs are opening up a spot on their list to use in the draft, that’s why they’ve done that and downgraded them to that rookie selection – I just think an extra category so they don’t need to have their name called out as part of the rookie draft, that’s what I’d do.

“In terms of them getting second chances in the rookie draft, the other alternative is clubs use the national draft to do it.

“There’s an appealing reason to do it for the clubs because it’s a one-year contract.”

Phil Davis, Andrew McPherson, Seamus Mitchell, Isiah Winder, Dylan Williams, Ed Curnow, Ryan Lester, Zane Trew, Paul Seedsman, Nakia Cockatoo and Kayne Turner were all re-rookied by their clubs on Wednesday.

Sportsday

More in AFL

Featured