Results

Trending topics

Select your station

We'll remember your choice for next time

How Andrew Thorburn case against Essendon could play out in court

2022-11-10T09:40+11:00

Last week it was revealed Andrew Thorburn has hired lawyers and reserved the right to sue Essendon, should he not get an apology from the club over his departure from Tullamarine.

Thorburn was appointed to the role of CEO at the Bombers before links to a conservative church that compared abortion to the Holocaust and described homosexuality as a sin were revealed.

The former NAB chief executive resigned within 24 hours of being appointed to the role and is seeking an apology.

However, if his dismissal does end up being heard in court, as is now possible, how would it play out?

Principal of Brydens Lawyers and Chairman of the Wests Tigers in the NRL, Lee Hagipantelis, broke down what could transpire.

“I think the understanding at the time was that Andrew had thrown himself on his own sword on the first day on the job because of the backlash of his role in that particular church, but now that he has engaged lawyers things may not be that clear,” Hagipantelis told SEN 1170 Breakfast.

“Now, if we go back and have a look at some of the comments made at the time and there’s one in particular that I found that was made by the Essendon president David Barham and he said that he had not been aware on some of the church’s views on homosexuality and abortion.

“But he was quoted as saying this: ‘basically this morning when the comments came out I went and saw Thorburn and it became really clear that Andrew couldn’t be chairman of that church with those views and CEO of the Essendon Football Club. In the end, Andrew decided he would stay with the church and couldn’t be CEO’.

“Now one might think, reading between the lines, that there might have been some encouragement from Essendon to resign.

“Now if that is the case and if Thorburn can establish that in court, then what may have in fact occurred would be rather than a resignation, it was a constructive termination.

“That occurs when an employer coerces or strongly encourages someone to resign and if he can establish in court that it was a constructive termination as opposed to a genuine resignation, then the court will determine whether the termination was lawful and if not lawful what are the damages that flow there from.”

The Herald Sun reported Thorburn was expected to earn $850,000 a year in the role.

Essendon remains on the hunt for a new CEO following Thorburn’s departure.

More in AFL

Featured