Results

Trending topics

Select your station

We'll remember your choice for next time

“I think that’s spin”: Cornes calls out Silvagni's defence of Paddy Dow

2022-10-06T09:17+11:00

Kane Cornes has called out Stephen Silvagni’s defence of Carlton midfielder Paddy Dow.

Dow is seeking a trade away from the Blues in the hopes of more consistent games at AFL level, after playing just the two (outside of being the sub) in 2022.

Carlton had a consistent midfield core across the season with Patrick Cripps, George Hewett, Adam Cerra, Sam Walsh and Matthew Kennedy, though Dow was overlooked consistently even when injuries opened the door.

Silvagni, who selected Dow at pick three in the 2017 National Draft ahead of the likes of Luke Davies-Uniacke, Cerra, Aaron Naughton and Zac Bailey, still believes in the 22-year-old.

“I think he’s an AFL player. I look at him and yes he didn’t get a lot of midfield time and he only played two games this year. Apparently his VFL form was outstanding,” Silvagni told AFL Trade Radio.

“Sometimes a new coach comes in and you’re not in his mix for whatever reason. He’s happy with another mix in the midfield – which obviously has happened.

“For Paddy it’s about whether he’s going to break into that midfield or whether he can find another position.

“His first year he played quite a bit in the midfield, but was shifted to a half forward flank which can be the death role.”

Cornes however completely disagrees on Dow.

“I think that’s spin. I don’t think Paddy Dow is an AFL player. I’m calling (SOS) out,” Cornes said.

“Five seasons into his AFL career, I know he was a high draft pick.

“If you’re only playing a handful of games in your fifth season of football, I don’t think he’s good enough.”

Matthew Lloyd believes Dow, who is contracted at the Blues for 2023, will likely have to stay and attempt to break into their best 22.

“He’s going to have to fight it out at Carlton,” Lloyd said.

“That’s a real reality check for players who at this time of year when the phone doesn’t ring and the manager doesn’t get any calls and you’re being told to wait until the end of the trade period with so many other deals that need to get done.

“I’m sure he’d love an opportunity somewhere else, but it doesn’t look like it’s coming for him.”

More in AFL

Featured