David King has numerous concerns about the Saints in 2022, culminating in his belief they’re not a “serious” finals team just yet.
The Saints are entering their third year under Brett Ratten, enjoying contrasting seasons in the two prior.
A successful 2020, involving an Elimination Final win against the Western Bulldogs was followed by a dire season last year, missing the eight in a backwards step.
However, they carried some momentum towards the backend of 2021, igniting hopes they can return to the form that had them tipped for the top four last year.
King watched St Kilda’s practice match against Carlton on Thursday morning and described some concerns early in the match.
“They’re impacted at the moment by some injuries, so it’s a difficult assessment to be making,” King began on SEN’s Whateley.
“But let’s just look at the way they’re playing. It’s really quick and frantic again, that was their model last year.
“I still worry about them defensively, it’s all well and good when you’ve got the ball and you go forward fast and they explode forward of the ball … I’m not a massive fan of it, I put it on the table early.
“I’m worried about St Kilda this season, the list could be a house of cards if they get a couple of injuries to the wrong players which they’ve already got.
“Where does it leave them with a difficult list? I still think they’re another three drafts away from being a serious four to five-year finals team.”
The Saints stocked up in the 2019 trade period, securing numerous stars in Brad Hill, Dougal Howard, Paddy Ryder, Zak Jones and Dan Butler.
They also secured Brad Crouch, Jack Higgins and Shaun McKernan the following year, but returned to the draft in 2021 with four picks.
Nick Coffield will miss the 2022 season with an ACL injury, while Dan Hannebery and Paddy Ryder both didn’t play in the club’s first practice game.
However, they’re both expected to be fit for Round 1.