Results

Trending topics

Select your station

We'll remember your choice for next time

“I can’t see any plan”: Former Matildas captain defends players, criticises coach

2022-01-31T14:39+11:00

Former Matildas captain Melissa Barbieri has defended the team, following their Asian Cup exit at the hands of South Korea in Pune.

The match appeared well within the control of Tony Gustavsson’s team early on, but they were unable to convert.

Three minutes before stoppage time in the second half, Sam Kerr’s Chelsea teammate Ji So-yun broke green and gold hearts with a sweet, swerving strike.

Barbieri, a goalkeeper who represented Australia on 86 occasions and went to four FIFA Women’s World Cups, believes there are deeper structural conversations to be had.

“It’s really disappointing for the girls, because they had their chances,” Barbieri told SEN’s Gilly and Goss.

“Sometimes it’s just not your day, and then the opposition goes down the other end and scores a cracking goal.

“There’s not much you can do about it but rue the chances that you had earlier in the match.”

South Korean custodian Kim Jung-mi tipped away a searing Mary Fowler effort with 19 minutes on the clock, and Kerr headed into the woodwork from the resultant corner.

In the 76th minute, Kerr went wide from a Cortnee Vine cutback, and the door remained ajar for their compact, disciplined opponents to strike.

With South Korea in the lead in stoppage time, left-back Steph Catley had a penalty shout turned down.

Kerr and substitute Hayley Raso were half a boot away from combining for an equaliser three minutes before the final whistle, but fortune did not smile on the Australians.

“Everybody is listening to (10 Football broadcaster) Andy Harper’s comments at the moment and he’s laying all the blame on Gustavsson,” Barbieri surveyed.

“It’s actually been a process of letting the girls down over a few years, in my opinion.

“A lot of them were told they must go play football overseas, a lot of them did, and a lot of them still didn’t get picked for the Matildas squad.”

Barbieri believes players have even been punished for pursuing a move overseas, having struggled for minutes in the places

Fortuna Hjørring midfielder Clare Wheeler played 90 minutes in the Matildas’ evisceration of Indonesia, operating at the base behind Fowler and Emily van Egmond.

19-year-olds Courtney Nevin and Holly McNamara were substituted on in the first and second group games, as was 23-year-old Cortnee Vine in the quarter-final.

The trio play at home in the A-League Women competition, however.

“These younger players that are coming through are playing overseas, but they’re barely playing, because they can’t get game time,” Barbieri lamented.

“They’re trying to get into positions where they’re playing at top notch clubs and not playing any games.

“You wonder, would it have been better if everyone who isn’t getting game time had just stayed in the A-League and got their game time up?

“Because a lot of our best players were in the A-League leading up to this tournament.”

Before the Asian Cup, Gustavsson said “it’s about trying to get results in this tournament, and winning the tournament.”

He picked an experienced squad, though with Tameka Yallop, Elise Kellond-Knight and Chloe Logarzo all sidelined by injury, the Matildas were missing some shape in the middle.

Regardless of the strategic balance of the team Gustavsson rolled out, Barbieri was frustrated by how he used the players at hand even in the context of the result.

“I was a bit baffled by his choices,” she recalled.

“Hayley Raso has been so amazing for us, and she’s come on in the dying minutes of this game.

“She’s been formidable for Manchester City. This is what I’m talking about. You’ve got players who go overseas and play, and players who go overseas and don’t play.

“Hayley Raso is one who actually played for Manchester City, and was dominating and doing great things, and then he doesn’t even start her.

“Unless she’s got an injury, that’s inexcusable for me. She’s always so dangerous.”

The other factor Barbieri identified was how the Matildas failed to play off their all-time leading goal scorer, feeling Kerr was left to carry the can after spurning two tight chances.

“The other thing is when you’re (coaching) an out-and-out striker like Sam Kerr and you don’t have a plan,” she shook her head.

“You’re like ‘what am I going to do to bounce the ball off this girl to get the ball forward into other areas,’ because if she’s being marked tight or having a bad game, someone else can be there.

“That’s the only thing I really agree with Harper on. They don’t look like they have a plan or a formation.

“Any coach knows you could sit down, watch a game and say ‘I can see what he’s trying to do here’ by what the players are doing.

“There is nothing. I can’t see anything, I can’t see any plan.”

Even after the early Asian Cup exit, Barbieri expects Gustavsson to take the Matildas to the home World Cup in 2023.

She cautioned that we may be looking at his tenure through another prism if not for Kerr’s late equaliser against Great Britain in the Matildas’ Olympic quarterfinal in Kashima.

Gustavsson’s side ultimately prevailed 4-3 in extra time, were defeated by Sweden in the semi-final stage and lost the bronze medal match 3-4 to the United States.

“He’s not a dead man walking,” Barbieri asserted.

“He can still go through with it, and he’ll be just saying ‘it’s a process, you win some you lose one.’

“(But) he’s lucky that he got through the Olympics! I mean, we were in this predicament against England, we wouldn’t have made it as far as we did if England hadn’t capitulated.

“We were trying to get to the semi-finals without having really dominated the tournament, and in this one he got beaten by a better South Korean side.”

The Matildas

More in Football

Featured