Melbourne’s premiership favouritism is suddenly on shaky ground after being stunned by the Giants by nine points at the MCG.
The Giants played like a team that was fighting for a spot in the eight, and were ferocious at the football.
They withstood and responded to multiple challenges from the Demons, a classy last quarter goal to Lachie Whitfield the highlight, throughout the afternoon to record a famous victory.
Hard nut Tim Taranto drove the standard with 28 touches and a goal, and Toby Greene was on fire early, setting up the victory with three first-half majors.
Rising defender Jack Buckley suffered a suspected ACL injury in a sickening collision early on in the first quarter, in the only sad note to what was an exceptional day.
Here’s everything you need to know!
Jekyll and Hyde GWS reap what they sow
The Giants would have been feeling a strong sense of deja vu.
For the second consecutive week they found themselves on the MCG, playing for a golden opportunity to leapfrog Richmond and cement themselves inside the top eight.
They also found themselves building a strong lead early, only to have that lead squandered as their opposition threatened to overrun them.
Last week they succumbed to that pressure – against Hawthorn – this week they did not.
Whenever the Demons threatened in the second half - mainly through Bailey Fritsch - the Giants never faltered, and consistenly responded.
When and where the Giants decide to turn up for four quarters is the biggest mystery in AFL right now, and one that would certainly cause coach Leon Cameron countless anxieties.
Last week Cameron lamented the gap between his side’s best and worst football, and admitted that his team wasn’t “in the eight because we’re not good enough to be in the eight yet".
Now they are in the eight, and they are good enough talent-wise, now it is up to them to develop some consistency and close that gap.
Are the Demons too midfield-heavy with Jack Viney in?
The Demons seemed to have a perfect midfield balance during the first half of the season whilst their contested bull and vice-captain Jack Viney was recovering from a toe injury.
Viney replaced Sam Weideman two weeks ago in the team, which isn’t exactly a like-for-like replacement, and they have lost the clearances in the two games he’s been in.
James Jordon took over the Viney role for the first half of the season, and certainly has been punching above his weight since his introduction to the team.
For the sake of team balance though, coach Simon Goodwin might have to make a decision on whether too much of a good thing isn’t as beneficial as it appears.
Is it time to unleash Ben Brown?
Simon Goodwin has been open about his uncertainty over what Melbourne’s best attack looks like.
Last week Ben Brown kicked five goals in the VFL, yet Goodwin was content with his forward line, who now have averaged a score of 62 in their last three weeks.
Having the best defence can only hide your attacking woes for so long, and so you have to wonder whether it’s time to unleash Brown, and give him a consistent run in the senior side and let him settle under Goodwin’s system.
What’s next?
A five-day break for Melbourne, before they take on Port Adelaide on Thursday night, with the match scheduled at Adelaide Oval pending COVID restrictions.
The Giants meanwhile are slated to take on the Gold Coast Suns. With both teams currently residing in Victoria for an unknown period of time, the date and time of the match is yet to be confirmed.
FULL SCORE
Melbourne: 1.3, 3.6, 5.9, 7.13 (55)
GWS Giants: 2.2, 6.6, 8.8, 9.10 (64)
GOALS
Melbourne: Fritsch 3, Neal-Bullen, Pickett, Salem, Sparrow
GWS Giants: Greene 3, Himmelberg, Kelly, Reid, Taranto, Ward, Whitfield
BEST
Melbourne: Salem, Petracca, Fritsch
GWS Giants: Greene, Kelly, Green, Taranto
INJURIES
Melbourne: n/a
GWS Giants: Jack Buckley (knee)
Stay up to date with all the latest news from SEN. Sign up HERE.