Collingwood was fined $20,000 by the AFL because Jordan De Goey accessed his and Jeremy Howe’s phones mid-game last Friday.
The likes of Garry Lyon and Gerard Whateley believed the AFL should come down hard on the duo, given the hypothetical integrity implications.
Kane Cornes however wonders why it’s such an egregious offence for injured players to grab their phones, meanwhile AFL coaches can have theirs with them in the box.
GWS coach Leon Cameron coincidentally had his phone next to him in the box during the club's Round 3 game. The AFL later stated that he was authorised to have it.
While Cornes isn't targeting Cameron, he does wonder about the broader differences between coaches and players and phone access.
“When I read $20,000 I thought gee that’s harsh. I thought it was a very minor offence for what they did,” Cornes told SEN SA Breakfast.
“The box is open, they’re injured, they want to text their family and they did that and no harm was done, so $20,000 I thought was a lot.
“But if we want to get serious with this and we start talking about $1 million and an 11-week suspension, which would almost be the harshest penalty the game has ever seen, why don’t we take phones off coaches?
“We’ve got coaches sitting in the coaches box who have far greater influence over the impact of a game than two injured players that will not go back onto the field.
“And yet Leon Cameron can have his phone sitting right next to him in full view of the television cameras.
“If he wanted to or if a coach wanted to, they can influence the impact of a game far greater than any injured player can.
“So why are the AFL allowing coaches to have phones, but are coming down so harshly on a couple of injured players who are going to take no further part in the game? I don’t understand it.
“Jordon Butts is a defender. To kick the first goal, I don’t know what that would be paying because I’ve got no idea about betting and odds, but I would think it would be $100.
“If a coach had the information that Butts was starting forward and you could get him for first goal scorer, I mean that’s the sort of stuff that can influence.
“I’m not saying a coach would ever do that and I’m not questioning the integrity of any player or coach, but they can have their phones in full view of the coaches box and there’s nothing to see, yet two injured players get smashed. I don’t get it.”
Were AFL investigators urged to delve into Leon Cameron's phone records after his phone was on the desk during the game pic.twitter.com/ZeDM9arITQ
— steve duckworth (@thegoldenduck05) April 20, 2021
