Results

Trending topics

Select your station

We'll remember your choice for next time

Why the Magpies could not cash in on Grundy’s ruck dominance

2021-04-02T08:31+11:00

The importance of the ruckman has again been called into question following Thursday night’s nail-biter between Collingwood and Brisbane.

The Lions won a thriller at Marvel Stadium after Zac Bailey converted a post-siren set shot to give his side a one point victory.

In the wash-up, one of the key talking points has been Magpies ruckman Brodie Grundy’s complete and utter dominance, and how it did not translate into four points for Nathan Buckley’s side.

Grundy won 54 hitouts (a massive 23 of which were to advantage) to Brisbane’s total of four between youngsters Tom Fullarton and Connor Ballenden.

However, the overall clearance numbers read 35-30 to the Pies, 24-17 in stoppage clearances to the black and white and 11-13 in centre clearances the Lions’ way. More importantly, the superiority of the dual All-Australian did not equate to a win.

Magpies coach Buckley explained how he believes the Lions were able to negate Grundy’s ruck supremacy by making it a battle around the contest at ground level.

“The topics this week were Lachie Neale, the ruck contests and Brodie’s apparent dominance with Oscar McInerney out, and whether Jordy De Goey plays forward or midfield,” he told reporters.

“There’s an overemphasis on certain parts of the game and one of the things there is an overemphasis on is hitouts. It’s not a stat that has a strong correlation.

“When you know you’re going to lose the hitouts, you can actually set up pretty well at ground level to be able to buffer that. That’s what sides without a dominant ruckman do.

“Brodie’s not just a hitouts ruckman, he follows up, he’s a midfielder, and he played particularly well. The hitout differential is largely irrelevant, it’s actually what we do at ground level with that.

“He still had hitouts to advantage but the hitout stat is a furphy. It’s what you actually do with it.

“We’ve had sides congest us the last couple of years. We understand the differential but we think we’re doing that ok. When we win the contest at the ground, we have great clearance results, but it was pretty even in the end on the ground.”

David King admits attempting to work out what a certain side is doing at stoppages is difficult but could not quite understand how the Magpies did not gain more of an upper hand on the Lions.

“The science of stoppages, you almost need to be the Minister for the Dark Arts to work out what’s going on,” King said on SEN Breakfast.

“I bow to people like Jordan Lewis and Gerard Healy who talk about stoppages in a different language.

“Having cover, having a striker running through, how aggressive you want to be, hit zones, all these sorts of things.

“I really don’t understand how you can dominate hitouts like that and even man on man. When Grundy stood in the ruck next to Fullarton and Ballenden, he could just move them around.

“I think he’s got to go back to grabbing the ball and kicking it forward. Or the smack (into space) is something different.

“They just had total control. We may see something different next week so let’s wait until next week and see whether they say, ‘ok, we need to mix it up a bit, we need do more’.

“It’s very rare you get a chance to totally control an area of the game like that.”

For the record, Grundy also had 28 disposals, six tackles and five clearances in a near best on ground display.

The Pies enjoyed a lead of as much as 25 points during the second quarter and were in front at three-quarter time but in the end could not hold off a courageous Brisbane outfit.

Chris Fagan’s men were looked after by the footy gods following last week’s one-point loss to Geelong where coincidentally it was Bailey who was denied a free kick near goal in the dying moments.

Buckley’s side hosts GWS at the MCG next Saturday night while the Lions will remain in Victoria ahead of their clash with the Western Bulldogs in Ballarat.

Collingwood Brisbane Lions

More in AFL

Featured