What became abundantly clear when compiling the 2021 edition of the AFL Movers and Shapers, the sixth since its inception, is that for all the might and power of a $7.6 billion industry, never before has the game been so beholden to others.
Politicians – federal and state – made it clear to the AFL the terms and conditions under which the game could proceed during a time of COVID. They never budged on health and safety regulations and border controls and the AFL wisely respected the science, followed regulations to the letter and were exemplary corporate citizens.
But it explains the abundance of political figures on the 2021 list. Victorian Sports Minister Martin Pakula was the gatekeeper of footy in his state, the cradle of the game. Annastacia Palaszczuk saved the season and guaranteed Queensland would be at the forefront of the AFL’s planning for generations to come. Mark McGowan kept the AFL on its toes all year, while Tasmanian Premier Peter Gutwein is starting to flex his muscle as well. Federal health minister Greg Hunt and the AFL also conferred regularly in the lead-up to the disjoined season.
Gillon McLachlan is the perennial No. 1 on this list, but more so in 2021 given how superbly he led the game through its biggest operational crisis in a century. But there could be no game without the players and players boss Paul Marsh was able to get them to agree not just to a hefty pay cut, but also a hefty relocation in order to get the season away.
And in six years, no player has stood head or shoulders over the competition as has Dustin Martin. He is the first player in that time to crack the top 10.
Movers and Shapers 50-41 HERE
Movers and Shapers 40-31 HERE
Movers and Shapers 30-21 HERE
Movers and Shapers 20-11 HERE
10. Eddie McGuire
Presenter, producer and broadcaster, former president, Collingwood FC
Last year: 8
McGuire’s sphere of influence was never more evident through much of 2020. He was among the first to be drafted to the AFL’s wartime ‘corona’ advisory cabinet and inside the room provided vast and deep knowledge based on half a century of devotion to the game as a fan, journalist and administrator. During the shutdown period, he was often the conduit between the game and the fans and used his various media platforms to calm the waters and assure the public that the AFL was across and planning for every contingency. Bubbling along behind the scenes for most of the 2020 season was Making Their Mark, the seven-part docuseries produced by Amazon Prime in conjunction with McGuire’s JAM TV production company. It will expose the AFL like never before to viewers in more than 240 countries and territories around the world. It was certainly the most ambitious and it might be the best media work McGuire has put his name to. What is different about McGuire is that he is no longer the Collingwood president. His 22-year tenure came to an abrupt end in February after his clumsy attempt to manage the fall-out from the club’s Do Better report into racism at the Magpies. His image might have taken a battering and it is hard to imagine Collingwood without him, but footy is great at forgiving and, even if he takes some time to withdraw from the game to cool his jets and to refresh and refuel, it is likely he will remain a powerful figure for as long as he chooses.
9. Martin Pakula
Victorian Minister for Sport
Last year: 30
Even before COVID, Pakula, a card-carrying Carlton tragic, had established a strong working relationship with Gillon McLachlan. They became regular and trusted confidants all though last year, from the very moment Pakula interrupted a meeting between the AFL Commissioners, the executive team, club presidents and chief executives on the morning of the AFL season launch to tell McLachlan the Victorian Government was likely to introduce bans on mass gatherings, which would mean no crowds at the footy in Victoria. Pakula greenlighted the League’s start to the season, its mid-year resumption and encouraged McLachlan to look to Queensland when the second COVID wave hit quickly and hard in early July. He also signed off the deal that allowed the AFL to relocate the Grand Final to the Gabba for one year, adding an extra year to the agreement with the MCC at the other end and securing several national drafts for the state over the next few years. The AFL is hoping for 50 per cent capacity at games in Victoria once the season gets underway. Any increase in that figure won’t be achieved without Pakula’s say-so.
8. James Warburton
CEO, Seven West Media
Last year: 6
Whereas head of sport Lewis Martin (No. 25) works hand in glove with the AFL, it is Warburton who signs the cheques and, thanks to COVID, Seven and the League had to sit down and hammer out a new agreement, after 81 days were wiped off the season and economic conditions plummeted. The two bodies reworked their deals and on June 11, just hours before the season’s resumption, Seven extended its agreement by two years, to the end of 2024, with Gillon McLachlan saying the League would pocket $730m or an average of $146m a year for free-to-air rights. What was striking about the negotiation was the complete absence of acrimony, in marked contrast to Seven’s renegotiation with Cricket Australia, which ended up in court. As Warburton said in the media release announcing the new deal, “... the AFL and Seven are a core part of each other’s DNA.”
7. Andrew Dillon
General Counsel, General Manager Game Development, AFL
Last year: 4
COVID meant that pretty much every major agreement at the AFL had to be altered – with venues, broadcasters, players, banks, sponsors and other key stakeholders. When Dillon wasn’t overseeing that, grassroots football was being shut down entirely, for half a season across most of the country and for an entire season in the game’s heartland, Victoria. Dillon remains Gillon McLachlan’s closest and most trusted advisor and, when the AFL boss took a call from Tiger chief executive Brendon Gale at 7am one day in early September in the Queensland hub, he called Dillon to join them for an impromptu meeting, fearing the worst. It is rare a major decision is made at the AFL without Dillon’s tick of approval.

6. Steve Hocking
General Manager Football Operations, AFL
Last year: 2
Hocking takes care of the AFL’s core business – the footy – and was intimately involved in several of the key outcomes from last season, starting with the move to 16-minute quarters, which many panned, but as a one-off move to get through the season, proved to be the right idea. He was deeply involved in the discussions about a reduced soft cap and brought his experience as the former footy boss at Geelong to the table. He also ticked off the tougher interpretation of the holding-the-ball rule following some grousing from Hawthorn coach Alastair Clarkson. The AFL Review Centre (ARC) was fully operational for the first time. This year, the new man-on-the-mark interpretation and further reduced interchange rotations will be watched closely. Footy has become too defensive – scoring was down again last year – and speeding up the game and hopefully increasing scoring is firmly in Hocking’s remit, with several rule changes and other tweaks on their way in 2021.
5. Dustin Martin
Superstar, Richmond FC
Last year: 18
Martin’s form plateaued last year to the point where “Is ‘player x’ the new ‘Dusty’?” started to get some traction on talkback radio and among those who deal in clickbait. It is doubtless Martin paid any heed to that debate whatsoever, but nevertheless he turned in a magnificent October, including a four-goal, best-on-ground performance that swung the Grand Final Richmond’s way, earning him an unprecedented third Norm Smith Medal. And with that, the discussion as to who is the best player in the competition is over for now. It is Martin and by a considerable measure. The more interesting debate is where he ranks among the best finals players, while he is now also in the conversation along with Kevin Bartlett, Jack Dyer and Royce Hart as the greatest Tiger of all time. Off the field, he remains an enigma. Apart from Bonds, he has no marketing deals of note and rarely speaks to the media unless compelled to. Max Gawn and Patrick Dangerfield he is not, but in every other respect he is the complete package. It is highly doubtful the Tigers would have those three flags in four years without him and, as long as he plays anywhere near his peak, they are every chance to win even more.
4. Richard Goyder
Commission Chairman, AFL
Last year: 3
It was Goyder who raised the first coronavirus alarm at the AFL last January, having spoken to Qantas boss Alan Joyce in his capacity as the airline’s chairman and been told that the national carrier was putting its crisis management team on to the case. Goyder then alerted Gillon McLachlan and asked him to engage in scenario planning in the event the AFL season had to proceed without crowds. The AFL Commission tends to be hands off when it comes to the management of the game. It sees its primary function as one of governance and oversight, but for much of 2020, it was all hands to the wheel and there were times when McLachlan and Goyder would talk up to 10 times a day. And Goyder chaired all the meetings between the Commission and the club presidents and CEOs, of which there were many. Another area where Goyder led the way was to manage the sometimes prickly relationship with the West Australian Government. The AFL was one of WA Premier Mark McGowan’s favourite punching bags – which irked some at the League – and it was left to Goyder, one of the state’s most prominent identities, to manage that important relationship. There was criticism in some quarters that Goyder and his team weren’t visible enough in 2020, which he bristled at, and he copped some heat for not being at the Grand Final at the Gabba. The four-week delay to play the decider wreaked havoc with his schedule and he wasn’t prepared to ask for a travel exemption, nor to miss Perth’s annual Telethon, the children’s health and medical research fund-raiser he also chairs, which last year raised $46m.
3. Travis Auld
Chief Financial Officer and General Manager of Clubs and Broadcasting, AFL
Last year: 11
There is no clear No. 2 at the AFL, but Auld and his people did much of the hard work as the League reinvented itself on the run. Broadcasting, fixturing and finance all came under his watch and he was a key player in the decision made back in March to at least get the season underway. Together with Steve Hocking, he was the AFL’s lead negotiator with the clubs over cuts to the soft cap and he pressed them hard, at one stage proposing reductions of nearly 50 per cent. He then did much of the heavy lifting with the Queensland Government when it came to relocating the season once Victoria became off-limits and then the arrangement to stage the Grand Final at the Gabba. His brief going forward will include all of the above as well as the Marvel Stadium/Docklands precinct redevelopment that is still going ahead with the support of the Victorian Government. If there is a lead internal candidate at the AFL to eventually replace McLachlan, it would be Auld.
2. Paul Marsh
Chief Executive, AFL Players Association
Last year: 7
Like everyone in footy, his year was turned on its head by COVID. He was the first person Gillon McLachlan called after receiving the news from Victorian Sports Minister Martin Pakula that the season was in trouble and together they worked closely on a revised pay deal that ended up ensuring the players received about 62 per cent of their entitlements for the year. There were some anxious moments – the AFLPA was disappointed not to have been consulted about the 17-game season before the decision was reached – but amid all the white noise in those frantic few days after the season was shutdown, he and McLachlan were able to hammer out a deal. Marsh then played a huge part in getting the players to agree to relocate to the hubs. There were legitimate concerns from the players about being away from home for such a lengthy period, but he won various concessions on their behalf and, in the end, the season was saved. Over six years with the AFLPA and several years with the Australian Cricketers Association before then, Marsh has established himself as one of the great labour leaders in all of sport. There has never been any indication he is looking to cross the great divide and join the AFL or one of the clubs in a senior capacity, but speculation was that Adelaide at least had a conversation with him about returning home to become the club’s next chief executive before Tim Silvers got the job.
1. Gillon McLachlan
Chief Executive Officer, AFL
Last year: 1
In the 2020 of his dreams, McLachlan would likely have enjoyed one last go around in the big chair at AFL House. Industry speculation was rife he was set to finish up some time towards the end of last year or during the early part of this season. Instead, he will be staying put for that bit longer. Footy needs to dig itself out of a major hole caused by COVID-19 and the focus is on McLachlan whose leadership at every level throughout 2020 was exceptional. The game needed to be flexible and agile last year and it started from the top. From the very beginning, McLachlan heeded the advice of the government and listened to science. He consulted widely and was happy to delegate key outcomes to his management team. Within a week of the game’s shutdown, bank loans had been secured and the pay deal with the players restructured to the satisfaction of both parties. He struck an excellent new deal with the TV broadcasters and in a 10-minute phone call with Premier Annastacia Palaszczuk convinced the Queensland Government to allow the AFL to pretty much relocate to the state for the remainder of the season. It was leadership as good as anything witnessed across the country during the pandemic and McLachlan’s army of admirers grew considerably over the year. He led with compassion and empathy and never made himself or the game bigger than it needed to be. It did take a personal toll; he was removed from his family for much of the year and there were times when he looked as though the weight of the world was on his shoulders. At times, his friends and associates were worried for his health. In the end, the financial losses weren’t quite as extensive as forecast and the game found a way to get through its most challenging period for a century and should return to reasonable health relatively quickly. The end of his time as CEO is probably on the horizon, but neither he nor the League would be in any hurry to make it happen.
Movers and Shapers 50-41 HERE
Movers and Shapers 40-31 HERE
Movers and Shapers 30-21 HERE
Movers and Shapers 20-11 HERE