Sydney’s decision to trade Toby Nankervis was the club’s biggest recruiting mistake of the last 20 years, according to former Swan Gerard Healy.
Nankervis was drafted to the Swans in 2013 and played 12 games in three seasons with coach John Longmire preferring Kurt Tippett and Sam Naismith as his ruck pair for the 2016 Grand Final.
Since joining Richmond for more senior opportunities, Nankervis has established himself as the club’s No.1 ruckman and played a key role in their premiership dynasty that has produced three flags in four years.
“The Swans have picked up a lot of good players over the years, value players,” Healy told Sportsday.
“The biggest mistake they’ve made as a recruiting group in the last 20 years was trading Toby Nankervis.
“(Tom) Mitchell was a shocker, but Toby Nankervis was also bad because the Swans have been desperately looking for a ruckman ever since.
“They’ve gone to the west and picked up two (Callum Sinclair and Tom Hickey), they’ve had kids coming in out of rugby union clubs trying to get them to become a ruckman – Toby Nankervis was there waiting for you, fellas.
“And he’s gone on to become a multiple premiership player and a star.
You don’t have to be a genius at the ruck craft to be a genius ruckman.”
Nankervis, 26, was one of Richmond’s best performers during last year’s finals series and has played 70 games since arriving at Punt Road at the end of 2016.