Collingwood coach Nathan Buckley has spoken for the first time about Eddie McGuire’s exit as president, saying his comments on the findings of the club’s ‘Do Better’ report didn’t “hit the mark”.
McGuire said the handing down of the report, which found there was systemic racism at the club, was a “proud and historic day” for Collingwood.
In the immediate aftermath of McGuire making those comments, the long-term Pies president announced he would leave the club with immediate effect, bringing forward his proposed exit which was forecast to come at the end of 2021.
Buckley said McGuire is “either loved or hated”, while admitting the “trauma” Indigenous people have felt in recent times at the club needed to stop.
"The more you put yourself in this position (in front of a microphone), the more likely you are to say something that's not quite going to hit the mark and I think that was one of them," he told AFL Media.
"He's owned that, we've owned that, and once again that reinforces potentially the trauma that Indigenous people or minorities have felt through the Collingwood Football Club's contribution. That simply has to stop now.
"He's either loved or hated. There's not a lot in between with Ed, and I think that's been a Collingwood way.
"There's years of a character that has been portrayed for Collingwood, and by Collingwood, so I understand that's a reality.
"Ed's probably fed into that in some ways and been a victim of it in others but the reality is to take our steps forward as an organisation we need to be more circumspect.
“We need to understand that we don't know it all, that we can be a leader in society let alone in the football industry."
In the expansive chat, Buckley conceded for the first time that he had dismissed Heritier Lumumba’s recent claims of racism across the football club.
Both Lumumba, Anthony Krakauer and Leon Davis have recently spoken out about how they were treated in their respective times at the club, saying they were subjected to racist abuse internally during their playing days.
Buckley said he had failed to acknowledge Lumumba’s experiences, pinpointing a specific incident at a press conference four years ago where he dismissed the claims.
There was a press conference I gave in 2017 when Heritier's documentary came out," Buckley said.
"I wasn't able to separate myself from the personal connection and the potential feeling of not having been able to have done enough in that circumstance to lift myself out of that to see the bigger picture which is that what Heritier's talking about, what Leon's talking about, what Andrew has spoken about, is their experience.
“Where they want to be and what we want the place to be – we're united in that. We don't want people to ever feel like they're diminished or vilified or seen as less than in our environment.
“If that is their experience then it needs to be acknowledged and for that I think the club has said it apologises unreservedly and obviously I have been a part of this club for a long time, so I don't like the fact that people have felt that way and I've got to – we've all got to – listen and learn more to the experiences and acknowledge them rather than dismissing them.”