Has Adelaide’s issues retaining interstate players at their club factored into their draft decision making?
The Crows took five players in Tuesday night’s National Draft, four of which were local products.
This included top selection Riley Thilthorpe at pick two and draft bolter Luke Pedlar at pick 11.
Adelaide has been hit hard by the trade period in the last decade, with Phil Davis, Jack Gunston, Patrick Dangerfield, Jarryd Lyons, Jake Lever, Charlie Cameron, Mitch McGovern, Eddie Betts, Hugh Greenwood, Cam Ellis-Yolmen, Alex Keath, Kyle Hartigan, Brad Crouch, Rory Atkins and more departing the club.
Kane Cornes wonders whether this build-up of talent choosing to leave the club has led to a change in strategy.
“I want to discuss the landscape of the Adelaide Football Club and whether they’ve been absolutely spooked by the players that have left or is it a coincidence that they were South Australians?” Cornes asked on SEN SA Breakfast.
“It’s a question and one that’s an unanswerable question for me because unless you’re inside the walls of the Adelaide footy club and unless you’ve seen these players play over the last three years, it’s tough to comment.
“What I would hope is that they aren’t limiting themselves or excluding themselves from the best players.
“We know that historically 60 per cent of the players get picked from Victoria and the under 18 competition over there, now the fact that that didn’t happen this year, clearly the numbers are going to be skewed that way,
“(With) all of the players that have left over the last 10 years I just hope they haven’t narrowed their focus to only South Australians so they don’t leave and that satisfies what is a frustrated supporter base.
“I feel somewhat sorry for (Crows recruiting manager) Hamish Ogilvie. His job is to pick the best player, not the best second best player because they’re South Australian.
“I’m just posing the question, as I said, I haven’t seen these players play.
“In fact, I’d hardly ever heard of Luke Pedlar, even though he’s a Glenelg boy and he’s turned out to be pick 11 for the Crows.
“They will know, but I’m just posing the question and I hope Adelaide isn’t hamstrung by the fact that so many players have left that footy club in recent times.”
Brownlow Medallist Adam Cooney thought similarly, feeling the Crows played it safe.
“We spoke about Adelaide and the retention issues that they have had over the last six to seven years. Phil Davis was probably the man who started it off,” Cooney told SEN Breakfast.
“I think they were gun shy from drafting Victorian talent. Their pick two from West Adelaide, there’s no doubt he’ll have an unbelievable career, then they picked Luke Pedlar who was a bit of a bolter.
“I’m not sure he would’ve gone at pick 11 if he was from Victoria.”
In total, 14 South Australian players were drafted overnight, including five in the first round – the most since 2010.