Results

Trending topics

Select your station

We'll remember your choice for next time

"It’s either right, or it’s wrong": Whateley weighs in on Rampe post climb

2019-05-13T09:41+10:00

SEN chief broadcaster Gerard Whateley has had his say on Dane Rampe jumping on the goal post, saying he’s perplexed by the AFL’s decision to tick off the call.

Rampe leapt onto the goal post while David Myers was having a shot at goal to win the game for the Bombers, with the umpires telling him to get down rather than paying a free kick.

“My questions is, it’s a bit like Pirates of the Caribbean, do we have rules, or do we have guidelines. Which one?” Whateley said.

“At the moment we are getting, it doesn’t matter what the decision is, it’s being ticked off on (by the AFL).

“Surely with rules it’s either right, or it’s wrong and the only way to improve is to go, hey this is right, and this is wrong.

“(The rule) specifically prescribes for this. It doesn’t matter whether it affects the game or not. If you wobble the goal post, out, it’s a free kick.

“Is it right or is it wrong, that’s it.”

Despite that, Whateley believes we’d be having the exact opposite discussion right now if the free kick had been paid, even if that outcome would have been by the letter of the law.

“The counterfactual is, if the free kick is paid, Myers’ kick comes up short and we march to the goal line and Myers wins the game on the second kick, does the footy world combust?” he said.

“I think if we’re honest, it would be a much bigger furore.”

More in AFL

Featured