At the conclusion of each round, we will dissect the five key issues that eventuated from the weekend’s games of footy.
Here is what we learned from Round 8...
Buckley’s tenure summed up in a day
Collingwood’s loss to GWS on Saturday epitomised Nathan Buckley’s coaching career.
Consider the factors. The Magpies showed their optimum can not only match, but better, one of the competition’s benchmarks. This was after a dismal effort against Carlton a week prior, a game where many questioned the Pies’ list, direction and game plan. Furthermore, Collingwood received across the board contributions, leaning on a talent-laden midfield to absorb personnel deficiencies up forward and down back. Injury issues were also involved, with Adam Treloar out of the squad. After taking all of this in, the result, as it has been so often for Buckley, was so close, but yet so far.
The Pies teased against the Giants. Managing to open a 26-point lead in the first quarter, Collingwood were running rings around their highly fancied opponents. Brodie Grundy was overawing Shane Mumford in the ruck, allowing Buckley’s midfield brigade to have first use of the ball. The Magpies controlled the footy, racking up 42 more disposals, with their potency a highlight. Absent was the hesitant, uncertain ball movement, replaced by an aggressive Collingwood outfit that isn’t seen enough.
This isn’t the first time a Buckley coached side has flashed potential. In fact, it is a usual occurrence, especially when their backs are against the wall. And, of course, for all of this positivity, what did the Pies have to show for it at the final siren?
A loss. Again.
The intent and desire weren’t lacking, but the polish and class was. This narrative has been embedded to Buckley’s coaching campaign. The silly, frustrating mistakes when the game was on the line, such as Jarryd Blair’s careless sliding free kick, Jordan De Goey and Ben Reid missing easy goals and Brayden Maynard failing to account for Steve Johnson at the game deciding contest, were on full display.
This creates the chicken and the egg argument. How can Buckley, up in the coaches box, control Reid kicking a point from 15 metres out? How can the coach claim accountability for his players giving away inexcusable free kicks? You’ll have people saying it isn’t Buckley’s fault, you’ll have others questioning his tactics and asking why he couldn’t get his team to maintain their incredible output from the first term.
Does all of this sound confusing yet? It should, because in just one game, we had the full Buckley experience. Despite the reasons remaining as foggy as ever, the final result, as it has been far too many times, was defeat and another step towards the inevitable.
The Demons have discovered a gem
Melbourne’s stirring victory over Adelaide helped consolidate one of footy’s modern theories.
A mobile, agile, marking and threatening ruck man is far more impactful and useful than solely a tap winning one. This isn’t to say Sam Jacobs, who would probably occupy the All-Australian ruck spot right now, isn’t versatile. However, Cam Pedersen was simply more adept around the ground and despite getting belted in hit outs 74-22, there is no doubt he won the battle of the two big men.
The individual match-up said far more about Pedersen than it did Jacobs. We know the Crow is one of the AFL’s best and he wasn’t the worst performer on a shocking night for Adelaide. Pedersen, though, was still seen by some as a player who was simply keeping the seat warm until Max Gawn and Jake Spencer regained full health. The 30-year-old has dismissed that notion, making that seat his own instead.
Pedersen’s beauty isn’t seen in the ruck. He is relatively undersized and has never averaged more than 4.8 hit outs in his career. This is mainly due to Pedersen never really having to fill a rucking gap, but he is now showing his full ability in that makeshift role.
Moving around the ground like a midfielder, Pedersen constantly made himself a presence. This was amplified when he moved forward of centre, his three goals vital in the Demons’ victory. Furthermore, the former Box Hill Hawk produced five clearances and nine of his 13 disposals were effective, optimising his chances.
There is no doubt Gawn walks into this Melbourne team, as he is one of the ultimate do-it-all rucks. Spencer, though, could struggle to push Pedersen out of the squad, as the latter’s unique skill set is simply too important to Simon Goodwin’s structure at the present time.
Blicavs is at a crossroads
Two years ago, Mark Blicavs won Geelong’s best and fairest and seemed to be one of the competition’s most peculiar talents. Since that time, though, the 26-year-old has fallen off a cliff and his career now stands at a crossroads.
The abolition of the third man up was always going to impact Blicavs, as he was the game’s best component of the tactic. However, no one could have anticipated how profound that effect would be, as it has robbed Blicavs of an identity and position.
Despite Chris Scott’s persistence to keep playing the Taylors Lakes product in the midfield, it is becoming painfully clear that he doesn’t possess the ability to do so. Blicavs isn’t collecting a lot of the footy, averaging 15.1 disposals, and he is turning it over far too often, totaling just 11.6 effective disposals per game. He looks uncertain and is devoid of confidence.
Blicavs, like many of his teammates, also isn’t applying the necessary defensive pressure around the contest. He laid no tackles against Essendon, displaying a half-hearted effort at the coalface.
Scott has plenty of decisions to make with his team and Blicavs is at the forefront. His form is becoming a worrying trend and not an outlier, with a VFL stint looming prominently.
Kelly is worth it
The more we watch Josh Kelly, the more he justifies North Melbourne’s million dollar offer for him.
Kelly is by far GWS’ most damaging midfielder, and his stellar performance against Collingwood enhanced his status. The former Sandringham Dragon amassed 36 disposals at an incredible 81 percent efficiency, gained 743 metres, had 17 contested possessions and 20 uncontested, applied 31 pressure acts, was involved in 10 scores and extracted seven clearances. It was an all-around effort of the highest order.
The Pies sent celebrated tagger Levi Greenwood to Kelly but that made no difference. The Giant was able to punish Collingwood on the inside and out, combining an impressive blend of pace, toughness, poise and calmness.
GWS is overflowing with young talent but retaining Kelly’s services has to now become an urgent issue. He is going to see big offers from rival clubs, and rightfully so. It’s up to the Giants to do all they can to keep him.
Freo’s pace is catching teams off guard
The final 21 seconds of Fremantle’s dramatic win over Richmond is going to be forensically analysed, but for a more accurate description of the Dockers’ purple patch of form, look no further than Michael Walters and Brad Hill.
Ross Lyon’s decision to move Walters into the middle has worked wonders, and combined with Hill’s blistering pace, the duo have became an impetus for Freo’s midfield.
The Tigers had no answer to Walters and Hill on the outside, with the former clocking up 449 metres and 24 uncontested possessions, and the latter even better, recording 588 and 26.
Walters and Hill were link-up players in the Dockers’ attacking chains and simply didn’t stop running all day. In a rare occurrence, Fremantle scored more points from clearances (39) than off turnovers (32), an indication of their ability to punish the Tigers on the outside.
Lyon’s teams have never been known for eye-catching speed and quickness. That narrative is shifting, though, thanks to Walters and Hill.