Dermott Brereton says that the undefeated Geelong still are no match for what he believes to be the two clear leading sides of the AFL right now: Adelaide and GWS.
The Cats recorded their fifth win of the season against St Kilda by 38 points on Sunday, storming home with an eight goal to one final term after a closely fought contest for the opening three quarters.
However Geelong’s 2017 has come under scrutiny by just how they notched up their victories – with all their wins coming against sides sitting outside the current top eight except for their opening round win over eighth placed Fremantle.
The five-time Hawthorn premiership player says that while he believes the Cats are a lock for the top six and a big chance of the top four, they currently do not matched the high-flying Crows and the highly-fancied Giants.
“I’m a believer that they’re top six, maybe deep up in there like top four,” Brereton said on SEN’s The Run Home.
“Right now the two best are GWS because the purity of their list is just insanely deep…and although I’d still like to see Adelaide get really tested by someone like Geelong, I think they have still done just that little bit more.”
Brereton also touched on their opponents on Sunday, believing the Saints’ gameplan just isn’t working right now.
“To me St Kilda don’t have a great game at the moment,” he said.
“I don’t know whether St Kilda go in each week and say ‘right, we’re a forward momentum, running scoring team’ or they’re a team that says ‘we park the bus and stop scoring.’ I don’t know what they think.
“I think the only thing they think is that ‘we’ll bring real heat to the centre of the ground, real pressure to the opposition and the rest will fall into place.’ That’s very true, but what if the opposition team bring as much heat to the middle of the ground and they have got one end tied up?
“I think the Saints need to figure what their strain is going to be within that game style.”